Editorial page

Monday, December 02, 2002
Our people are dying

Go ahead. Drink all you want. But don't come crying for help when your friend is dead, your mother brutally beaten, or you end up in jail.

It's that simple. Booze hurts. Booze kills. Then we lash out at others for the problems it causes.

And there's no reason for it.

Go to Holman and ask baby Joretta's parents. They know. Their precious bundle of joy died last March after she was dropped in the snow.

Her dad passed out on the doorstep of their home on his way back from a party.

He doesn't face criminal charges, and the coroner won't call an inquest. He knows all to well how Joretta's death could have been prevented.

Or read about Rebecca Francis' grief in today's News/North. She mourns the tragic death of her son in Fort McPherson last week. He was stabbed to death in her home. Her daughter -- his sister -- has been charged with second degree murder.

Police say alcohol was a factor in ripping yet another family apart.

Tuktoyaktuk is feeling the pinch, too.

Territorial Court Judge Brian Bruser minced no words as he tore a strip off townsfolk for their disrespect of authority.

Most of the problems in the Delta hamlet are caused by alcohol.

Police wouldn't be accused of excessive force if people weren't drinking to excess. People wouldn't be before the court if they restrained their alcohol consumption.

The RCMP is just enforcing the law: trying to get a handle on public drunkenness and all that it brings.

We could go on ...

Unfortunately, we're losing the battle with the bottle. More people have jobs and can afford to buy liquor -- so they do.

Police are stretched to the limit to deal with case after case. People are dying. Our communities are being torn apart.

Yes, the territorial government must do more: a detox treatment centre in the North is critical because without one our economic success will mean social disaster.

The blame must not stop on their doorstep.

If Northerners are truly committed to winning this fight, the solution starts at home. Instead of buying that flat of suds or 40-pounder of whiskey, put the cash toward a special alcohol-free dinner for family and friends.

You'll be sober and safe, and no-one will die.


Court should have banished Nakashook

Convicted sex offender Davidee Nakashook received a rather light sentence earlier this month after the Nunavut Court of Justice found him guilty of sexually assaulting an intoxicated 17-year-old woman.

Justice Beverly Browne sentenced him to time served plus a day and a three-year probation order. Nakashook must also seek counselling for substance abuse and has a 10-year firearms prohibition.

Essentially, Nakashook walked away a free man -- free to live wherever he chooses.

The sentence is difficult to accept. Nakashook is a repeat offender with 35 criminal offences on his record, most of which are violent and alcohol-related. The latest crime by the 46-year-old -- assaulting a drunk teenager at a house party -- is grotesque.

Nakashook did spend 14 months in remand awaiting trial and sentencing. Courts normally double that and take it off the sentence. In this case, it's problematic.

Nakashook was released without ever being rehabilitated. Because he was still considered innocent while in remand, Nakashook was not eligible for rehabilitation programs.

That means as he sat in a cell he did not have access to sex offender rehabilitation programs, social workers, psychiatrists or job training.

Could not he have remained in jail to receive appropriate counselling and treatment for a year, then serve two years probation?

The banishment order requested by the residents of Cambridge Bay was also denied. The people who Nakashook grew up with no longer want him to live among them. They are tired of his habitual, drunken violence and they asked the court to make him live somewhere else. It's also traditional practice.

Yes, that would only transfer Nakashook and his behaviour to the shoulders of another community.

Nakashook said he wants to make his home in Iqaluit or Gjoa Haven and only plans to return to Cambridge Bay to visit. Residents in those communities must now worry that a dangerous criminal may move in next door. Banning Nakashook from residing in or travelling to his home-town, Cambridge Bay, would have drove home the message that his actions are unacceptable.

The judge told Nakashook to carry the hamlet's banishment request with him at all times so he would remember the serious nature of the crime. But can we trust this 36-time offender to exercise good judgment and change his criminal ways? Surely that requires serious, committed rehabilitation.

Instead, Nakashook walked out of jail. We hope the sentence works, that Nakashook will get the counselling he needs. If not, someone else, in another community, could pay the price.


Better late than never

Help is on the way. It's not as soon as we'd like, but at least council has seen fit to hire four new firefighters. They start April 1.

The nearly $1.9 million cost of the city's fire department, which combines fire and paramedic services, is for the most part cheaper than other cities of a similar size. Factor in the fact we have much more emergency activity (2,294 annually) than Grande Prairie. Consider that Whitehorse (Pop. 22,000) spends $3.8 million on its fire department alone.

Even with the $250,000 a year the extra hands will cost, council has to remember the city will still have a bargain on its hands.


A recipe for debt recovery

Editorial Comment
Darrell Greer
Kivalliq News


The hamlet of Rankin Inlet is to be commended for the way it's going about collecting on some old debts.

Not only has the hamlet managed to recoup $100,000 so far, it has done so in a way sympathetic to the financial status of those owing.

As fair as the hamlet has tried to be in reaching agreements with those in arrears, there are still a number of residents forcing the issue.

We agree with Coun. Justin Merritt when he says anyone who hasn't responded to three notices is simply ignoring a situation and hoping it goes away.

However, how do people reach that point?

In this particular situation, it could be a case of old habits are hard to break -- and this old habit is one of not having to pay.

When hamlets first began taking over land leases from the GNWT about five years ago, they did so in groups or sections.

The first section the hamlet of Rankin Inlet took over contained about 100 lots.

It quickly became obvious the GNWT hadn't been making much of an attempt to collect on monies owed.

In a nutshell, the government of the day had become lazy and downright careless in dealing with the accounts.

That indifference has rubbed off on a number of residents.

To their way of thinking, they never paid the territorial government, why should they pay the hamlet?

So, just how indifferent had the GNWT become?

When the hamlet asked the GNWT for a receivables list on the people who owed money on the first 100 lots, the government handed over a box full of what looked to be recipe cards.

People working for the hamlet at the time say it resembled what someone might use to run a hockey pool.

Your tax dollars at work!

Apparently, the way this high-tech system worked -- when a person came in to pay for a year, whomever was handling the accounts would take a marker and scratch that year off the recipe card.

In short, the hamlet was left with no way to verify the money owed on the lots without invoices or statements of accounts.

Seeing what it was given to work with at the beginning, the hamlet's progress in collecting past due accounts becomes all the more impressive.

The hamlet is giving everyone a fair chance to pay in a manner they can afford, and that's the right approach to take in this situation.

As for how it ever reached such a ridiculous point and the length of time involved -- let us borrow a line in saying, "Now you know the rest of the story."


Real drug education

Editorial Comment
Terry Halifax
Inuvik Drum


Business is booming for Ed Secondiak at E.C.S Safety Services.

Ed's booked solid doing drug testing and education all over Alberta and the North, but this is one business we'd all like to see go out of business.

During his presentation, Ed played a video about the adverse health effects of smoking marijuana and it took me back to Grade 8.

When I was in junior high, we got all the usual low-grade health films about the evils of booze and drugs and they were a joke to us then and would be hilarious to watch today.

They showed us films portraying pot smokers as raving lunatics and drinkers as slathering boobs.

My friends and I tried pot and booze somewhere around that time and we collectively thought, "Our teachers lied to us!"

We felt that if they lied about pot and booze, they probably lied about that other stuff too, so off we went into our senior high years experimenting.

I was a lucky one. I never had much of a penchant for waking up broke and stupid, but as I grew older, I lost many friends who died drunk behind the wheel or overdosed on cocaine.

A guy I grew up with lost his house, his BMW and his carpentry business because of his addiction.

Those movies we watched in health weren't of much benefit to my friends and I and maybe even served us more harm than good.

Drug education has to be real to young people if it's going to have any effect.

Our schools are always eager to bring in shining examples of good citizenry, but if the students saw a few bad examples it might go a long way to preventing a problem before it becomes one.

If my health class had some guy come in and tell us how he lost his house, business and BMW to cocaine, who knows, I might have a few more friends today.

Renaissance revival

It's been a long time coming, but it's great to see the GNWT has finally made a commitment to an artisan training program for the territory.

While still in its infancy, the Aurora College program shows some real promise to future artists.

The beauty of the artisan program is that it offers students the full spectrum of arts that will give them a better understanding and appreciation of their own and other's work.

Whether carving, beading or sewing, these art forms carry a big part of the heritage of this area and recognizing that, the government will see their dollars come back through taxes paid and will help preserve a culture that needs all the help it can get.

Let's hope the next budget makes room for art.


A place to go

Editorial Comment
Derek Neary
Deh Cho Drum


Gauging village council There are a couple of noteworthy items from last Thursday's village council public meeting in Fort Simpson.

First of all, there weren't many people in attendance. The mayor, seven councillors and the senior administrative officer were almost as many in number as the crowd for a while. The audience peaked at 17, which isn't overwhelming. The previous mayor and council packed in double or triple that number on at least one occasion.

So then, should the poor turnout at last week's public meeting be interpreted as tacit approval of council's performance? Perhaps, but not necessarily.

Even though it had been a long time -- at least a year or two -- since the last public meeting, the current "hot button topics" of privatizing garbage and amending the smoking bylaw weren't enough to attract many residents -- and that's even on a week when TV bingo was cancelled. So it does seem to indicate that council isn't doing too poorly.

The other point of interest was that council is split on the two aforementioned issues and it turned out that the public is divided in opinion as well, at least those who showed up were. That would seem to indicate that council reflects its constituents, and that much is reassuring.

One issue that was not on the agenda, but was raised by resident Ken Lambert, was the disparity in services offered to those who live in Fort Simpson proper as opposed to those who live in the Wild Rose Acres subdivision. Lambert noted that Wild Rose residents have no fire hydrants, no sidewalks, no sewage or water lines. Therefore he suggested that Wild Rose residents should be paying lower property taxes.

Mayor Tom Wilson replied that if taxes go down in one area, they will have to go up in another. Coun. Sean Whelly added that it's expensive to truck water to Wild Rose residents, but the village subsidizes that.

While there hasn't been a hue and cry over the Wild Rose versus in-town issue lately, it is a sore point that never seems to go away.

With talk of another subdivision being built in Fort Simpson in the coming years, the tax for services topic is one that should be examined.

Going to be slick

Unseasonably warm weather has made a brief return to the Deh Cho and it's bound to be ultra slippery on the streets and sidewalks this week. The warm temperatures will likely melt some of the snow and then give way to cold temperatures, which will make things treacherous. Be cautious behind the wheel and on foot.