Editorial page

Friday, August 20, 1999

Clean up or pay up

The recent enforcement of the unsightly properties bylaw has some Yellowknifers crying foul over having to clean up property or face fines.

These bylaws protect community property values, ensure a healthy tax base and keep the community safe for our children.

How would you feel if someone started collecting scrap metal next door to your brand new bungalow?

While your neighbour's "stash" grows and grows, your real estate value plummets, as does the value of all the real estate nearby.

Consequently, with the shrinking value of your neighbourhood, the municipal tax assessment also drops.

While lower taxes are always appealing to homeowners, the community will inevitably suffer a lower tax base which could mean a loss of services, less repairs and maintenance on city property.

Either that, or rate payers face inflated property taxes which make real estate even less saleable.

Unkempt yards, unfinished construction projects and urban scrap yards can be potential death traps to children.

Kids looking for a place to hide or seek, scrounging for material for that new go-cart or just taking a short cut on the way home from school, could lead to injury or death in these hazardous residential areas.

In any society we have to respect the rights of others.

In the North, one man's "unsightly" is another man's "stash" and we need to respect the rights of both.

When the residential stash grows to the size of a scrap yard, it's time to move it to an area of town zoned industrial.

These laws are in place to protect the rights of the whole community but need to be tempered with the understanding of the individual.


Delay ill-timed

Yet again, we find the needs of industry, of business, of the people who actually DO something put on hold to accommodate the whims of politicians.

Diavik expected word this month from DIAND about its environmental review so it could start planning, assuming everything was a go, to make the most of the ice road season.

Unfortunately, our prime minister also felt the need to shuffle the cabinet in Ottawa, most likely to let everyone know how firmly in charge he is.

New DIAND minister David Anderson has put the Diavik assessment on hold until he catches up. Hopefully, he does so before the ice road deadline expires.

It is strange how the wheels of commerce can be brought to a screeching halt because the politicos decide to do, do, do the Ottawa shuffle.


Hits and Misses

"In the red corner, from North of 60, weighing in at 118 pounds of fighting fury..."

Wait a minute, we thought we were at a beauty pageant. At the crowning of Miss Teen Canada International recently, Yellowknifer Nicole Gagnon, who was last year's winner, was involved in a kerfuffle with one of the organizers.

Perhaps there is no stemming the inevitable, perhaps these days the way to determine the winner is a few rounds in the squared circle. It would certainly be more conclusive than the subjective criteria that currently resolves the question.

On the other hand, maybe these outbreaks of overt aggression are just a sign of the times. The conformist, arbitrary standards that govern beauty pageants are no longer relevant. These kind of contests have had their day. Let's move on to some other measure of worth. Before someone gets hurt.


To fight or not to fight?
Editorial Comment
Daniel MacIsaac
Inuvik Drum

The recent close call at Tsiigehtchic had what appears to be a happy ending. Cool, wet weather has contained an immense forest fire and Resources, Wildlife and Economic Development (RWED) is to be praised for keeping it at bay.

But the raging fire that doubled in size in the space of just a few days of hot weather has produced as many lingering questions as it did smoke. Tsiigehtchic residents, and even Mackenzie Delta MLA David Krutko, have criticized the government for not doing more to fight the fire at an earlier stage -- particularly because it grew to the point where it's been burning land that belongs to the Gwich'in, as well as Crown land.

RWED explained that it maintains a set of criteria, guidelines by which it decides what action to take against a fire. This blaze began in an area abundant with lakes and was slowed because of a cold July. Fighting a fire takes money -- one thing we've all been hearing that the government has too little of -- and by August this fire had grown to the point where fighting it was a virtual impossibility. In the end, forestry management chose to go the route of strategic operations against it, protecting buildings in its path and creating control lines free of fuel.

Whether the decisions made at the fire's outbreak were proper or not will doubtless remain open to debate. But what is perhaps more important now is examining how the fire affected Tsiigehtchic and what happened during those critical days two weeks ago.

The community had plans to evacuate to Inuvik if necessary, but then the threat of the fire jumping the Dempster made them consider Fort McPherson. Chief Grace Blake gave credit to RWED, but also complained about the lack of communication with the government and with Yellowknife during a critical time.

Tsiigehtchic's own emergency measures plan is now being reviewed. Perhaps this is also a good time for the government to have a look at its own policies and procedures and, most important of all, to address Tsiigehtchic's concerns and questions. The government must ensure that its emergency response strategy is as streamlined and efficient as it can be.

Because of RWED's forestry management team, no lives or structures have been lost to this fire -- but the people of Tsiigehtchic also lived through some very smoky, hot days.


A much needed exercise
Editorial Comment
Derek Neary
Deh Cho Drum

It certainly wasn't an exercise in futility.

The multi-agency "mock disaster" held in Fort Simpson last week proved that the RCMP, fire department and health centre staff are quite capable of handling a small plane crash such as the one they staged.

The exercise caught most residents by surprise and attracted a number of people to the airstrip to try to get a look at the proceedings. Rumours quickly circulated about what might have happened. Some people have even complained about the exercise, contending that it wasn't necessary to get people worked up for nothing. Well, it wasn't for nothing. Without practising for such an occurrence, there's no possible way to know how local emergency response teams would perform under similar circumstances. If everyone knew precisely what was going to happen and when, and simply showed up for the sake of showing up, what would that prove?

Of note, the firefighters were without their chief, deputy chief and captain. They also had three newcomers amongst their ranks, but still came through in the clutch -- not just during the exercise either. Three days earlier most of the same crew responded to an intense trailer fire and contained it before it got out of hand.

There were some humorous aspects to the exercise, though. 'Victim' Shawna Kidd did an amazing job of wailing in agony for close to an hour. Afterwards, she said she hopes her convincing performance won't be forgotten at Academy Awards time.

Although the firefighters weren't told there would be an exercise at 9 a.m., they were given the heads-up to expect something at some point on Friday. On the other hand, RCMP Const. Charles Quartey wasn't forewarned of the exercise and naturally assumed the accident was the real thing. He was admittedly baffled by the absence of skid marks behind the plane, how calm Simpson Air owner (and onlooker) Ted Grant remained, and fire Chief Pat Rowe's refusal to lend a hand despite being only a few hundred feet from the accident scene. Rowe was observing and evaluating the exercise. Despite initially being unaware, Quartey remained composed and even remembered to tell me to stay back from the scene. Pesky reporter!

By the way, practically everyone, including myself, was using the term "mock disaster" to describe the exercise. Technically, as Dr. Shane Barclay has pointed out, a "disaster" overwhelms the available resources. This one was designed to put them to the test, but was manageable. By all reports, they performed admirably.

Kudos to Ted Grant too, for allowing one of his airplanes to be used for the exercise.

Thanks to the DCFN

Due to an oversight on my part, the Deh Cho First Nations never received credit for two photos in last week's paper. The DCFN, through James Sergeant and Denia Lamothe, supplied the picture of the chiefs and elders (in the photo spread) and the one of Shirley Bonnetrouge. My thanks to them.


No teeth to regional tiger
Editorial Comment
Darrell Greer
Kivalliq News

It will be more than a little interesting during the coming months to see just how efforts to revive the regional Kivalliq Chamber of Commerce, as well as getting chambers up and running in Rankin Inlet and Baker Lake, pan out.

While there can be no denying the fact the establishment of these chambers could reap huge benefits to the Kivalliq Region, it remains to be seen whether business leaders in the region have the wherewithal to actually make it happen.

The most interesting of all the points to unravel as this scenario plays itself out, may very well be if, indeed, as acting Kivalliq chamber president Tom Kudloo says, "Kivalliq business people are very united in wanting to promote the entire region for the benefit of local people," is anything more than so much ballyhoo.

Small to middle business personalities in the region seem genuinely sincere in their expressed desire to promote the Kivalliq as a whole.

However, as anyone who does business in the Kivalliq Region can readily attest, it's not the small or middle business people who yield the power in this neck of the tundra.

Until some of the bigger players in the Kivalliq business community, most of whom head up the multi-armed conglomerates of which we're all aware, lend their voices in support of a regional chamber, any such organization would be a paper tiger at best.

In fact, the harsh reality of the situation is that most of the region's "big players" would have relatively little, if anything, to gain by the formation of a regional chamber of commerce.

They already have the information gathering resources at their disposal to gain the edge, or inside track, on any pending major business developments, as well as the financial ability to push themselves to the forefront of any open tendering process or competitive contract negotiations.

One need really look no further than to the company currently providing fueling services to the NTPC stations across the Kivalliq to see just how far the long arm of influence of our region's power brokers actually reaches.

It's no great secret business leaders across the Kivalliq Region play hardball with competitors, local or otherwise.

And, unless these same people start to have a revelation on the virtues of unanimity, a united chamber focused on benefitting local people through mutual promotion and co-operation will remain the idyllic musings of those who long for a better world.