UN official says Crown didn't
understand indigenous peoples

by Arthur Milnes
Northern News Services

HAY RIVER RESERVE (Feb 20/98) - Non-indigenous people making treaties with the Dene lacked an understanding of the fundamental importance of the indigenous relationship with the land.

This is the view the UN's special rapporteur on treaties, agreements and other constructive arrangements between indigenous people and state governments, Miguel Alfonso-Martinez, says he has taken with him after three days of discussions with native delegates at the Hay River Reserve last week.

"Above all, there were very different interpretations of the intentions for these (Dene) people," he told the Drum by phone from Havana, Cuba, Monday night. "There was a lack of understanding by non-indigenous people of the relationship between the people and the earth."

This was made to clear to the UN special rapporteur -- who will be filing a report to the UN General Assembly this summer -- after presentations by leaders, elders and other delegates from around the area last week.

He had come to the Hay River Reserve after being approached by former Deh Cho First Nations (DCFN) grand chief Gerald Antoine in Switzerland last year. The visit was designed so that Alfonso-Martinez could hear evidence on Treaty 8 from 1899 and Treaty 11 from 1921 between the Crown and Northern aboriginal peoples.

"I want to tell you something from my heart," delegate Roy Fabian said during last week's proceedings. "This land is alive and this earth is our mother... All knowledge and skill come from the land...We need the land to be Dene people."

DCFN Grand Chief Michael Nadli also briefed the visitor on the Deh Cho Proposal.

"In a nut shell, we are proposing that our Dene form of governance, which (in) good part we still practice, be recognized by the federal and provincial governments of Canada, as the public government for the Deh Cho territory," he said. "This is a government based on Dene laws and customs. We have a ways to go to develop it to meet full, current public requirements, but we feel strongly that this is the only way our cultural and legal obligations, including treaty obligations, will be met; and, that our rights will be respected."

Alfonso-Martinez also said he wanted to leave those at the conference with another important message.

"The important thing is not to understand history but to change it," he said.